Blog
How to Measure Authentication Success Rate for Integrations
Metrics

How to Measure Authentication Success Rate for Integrations

Learn how to calculate authentication success rate for integrations, separate initial setup from token refresh, and find credential friction before it disrupts customer processes.
Nov 18, 2026
Brian Munz
Brian MunzDeveloper Advocate
How to Measure Authentication Success Rate for Integrations

Post 7 of the Integration Health series

Key takeaways
  • Authentication success rate counts attempts and not executions. Authentication that fails during setup, after revocation, or at token refresh often leaves no failed execution, so failed executions are a poor proxy.
  • Authentication setup, reconnect, and refresh should be tracked separately. Low setup success usually means onboarding friction, low reconnect success points to revoked or invalid access, and low refresh success may mean that integrations look healthy until they need a new credential.
  • Each authentication attempt requires start and end definitions. What marks an attempt as begun and what counts as complete? In addition, decide how cancellations, invalid credentials, revoked access, and provider outages are classified.
  • Segmenting by connector and method exposes underlying issues. A portfolio average can hide a failure that's found in one connector, customer segment, or auth method.
  • Authentication success says nothing about execution outcomes. A credential can be accepted, and the run can still fail with an API error, rate limit, or something else. Use the rate with time to first successful execution and execution error categories to separate setup friction from later problems.

Authentication can fail before an integration runs a single time.

A customer may abandon an authorization flow during setup. A credential may be revoked months later. Or a token refresh may fail before the next execution needs it.

If you look only at execution outcomes, these authentication problems can be difficult to distinguish from other failures, or they may not appear until they have already interrupted customer work.

Authentication success rate measures how often authentication attempts complete successfully. Tracking it by authentication stage and method helps show where customers encounter friction and where credentials are failing.

Who needs this

Everyone with integrations needs to know when authentication issues prevent customers from connecting or affect integrations that were previously working.

Tracking initial auth failures separately from token refresh and reconnection failures helps you separate onboarding friction from credential problems in production. It also reveals failures that execution metrics miss completely (because the integration never executed).

Watch the video

Watch the overview, or keep reading for the details.

Authentication success rate

What is authentication success rate?

Authentication success rate is the percentage of authentication attempts that complete successfully during a defined period.

Authentication success rate (%) = Successful authentication attempts ÷ Total authentication attempts × 100

An authentication attempt might be an initial setup, a reconnect, or an attempt to refresh an existing credential. Those attempts represent different moments in the execution lifecycle, so calculate and report them separately.

Before counting attempts, define what marks an attempt as started and what counts as success. For example, decide whether success means the authentication flow reached its completion state, rather than assuming that a completed flow guarantees later business executions will succeed.

If you’ve had 1230 authentication attempts within the last 30 days, but only 843 of them were successful, you have an authentication success rate of 68.54%.

Authentication success rate

ct
ct
Authentication success rate
68.54%

Why authentication success rate matters

Authentication is a prerequisite for most integrations, but it is not the same as execution success. If authentication fails before an execution begins, there is no failed execution to explain the problem.

A low initial-authentication success rate can point to friction during onboarding. Customers may be having trouble completing authorization, choosing the right account, or supplying valid credentials.

A low reconnect rate can indicate problems when customers need to restore access – for example, after access is revoked or a credential is no longer valid.

A low token-refresh success rate can expose a different risk. Existing integrations may appear healthy until they need a refreshed credential. If refresh fails, later work can be interrupted even though the integration had previously been running.

The metric does not tell you whether an integration moved the expected data or completed its business workflow. It tells you whether authentication attempts succeeded. Pair it with execution success and time to first successful execution to understand what happens before and after authentication.

Keep authentication attempts separate from executions

An authentication attempt is not necessarily an execution, and one execution may not represent one authentication attempt. Avoid using failed executions as a proxy for authentication failures: that misses problems that stop work before execution starts and can mix authentication issues with failures that happen later in the workflow.

Likewise, a successful authentication does not guarantee a successful execution. The integration can still encounter an API error, rate limit, schema mismatch, or data-processing problem after credentials are accepted.

Keep the following distinct in reports, since each measures a different thing:

  • Authentication success rate uses authentication attempts.
  • Execution success rate uses expected executions.
  • Time to first successful execution uses elapsed time to a successful run in production.

How to measure authentication success rate

1. Separate the authentication populations

Report initial setup, reconnect, and token-refresh attempts as separate populations. Combining them can hide where the problem occurs: a healthy refresh rate could obscure setup friction, or successful setup could mask credentials that fail later.

2. Define attempt outcomes

Document what counts as a started attempt and a completed success. Decide how to classify outcomes such as user cancellation, invalid credentials, revoked access, and provider outages. Keep those outcomes visible rather than silently excluding them from the denominator; if you exclude or group an outcome, state the rule and apply it consistently.

3. Calculate the rate for a defined period

For each population, divide successful authentication attempts by all authentication attempts in the reporting window, then multiply by 100. Use the same attempt and outcome rules across periods so that changes in the rate reflect real changes (and not alterations in the formula).

4. Segment the results

Report the rate by connector, customer segment, and authentication method. A single portfolio average can hide a problem concentrated in a single connector or auth method.

When the rate changes, review the outcome categories and relevant connection or authentication events. The rate indicates how often authentication succeeds, and the categories help explain why it does not.

5. Pair it with downstream measures

Compare authentication success with time to first successful execution and execution error categories. This helps separate setup friction from problems that occur after a connection is established and shows whether authentication issues delay a customer's first working integration.

What Prismatic provides

Depending on the connector, event, and configuration, connection data and alerts can help expose authentication failures. Configuration flows can also help route customers toward remediation. Many connections exist outside a deployed instance, so a single connection can affect multiple instances.

Connector-level data can help teams identify authentication methods that may need clearer documentation or an improved customer experience.

In addition, Prismatic supports alert monitors specifically for OAuth 2.0 refresh failures.

Prismatic provides operational evidence for this metric. Your team still needs to define the attempt, success, outcome categories, reporting period, and segments.

Where to start

If you are beginning to track authentication success rate:

  • Define what counts as an authentication attempt and a successful completion.
  • Separate initial setup, reconnect, and token-refresh attempts.
  • Decide how cancellations, invalid credentials, revoked access, and provider outages appear in the results.
  • Report by connector, customer segment, and authentication method.
  • Pair the rate with time to first successful execution and execution error categories.
  • Review low-performing segments to identify whether the next step is product, documentation, customer success, or a connector investigation.

There is no universal target for authentication success. Establish a baseline for each population, then set targets according to customer impact and the needs of the workflows that depend on those credentials.

The important first step is to measure comparable authentication attempts separately from business executions. That makes it easier to see where customers get stuck during setup – and where existing integrations lose access later.

Series navigation

Post 6: Retry rate and retry recovery rate

Post 7: This one.

Post 8: Coming soon

View all the posts in the Integration Health series.

Get a Demo

Ready to make your product extensible?

Join teams from Fortune 500s to high-growth startups that turned integrations into a growth driver and made their products the foundation that customers build on.